Detailed Findings
Rising Dessert Prices
3.2% Increase in Dessert Costs (2023–2024): Desserts at restaurants have become pricier year over year, contributing to consumer reluctance to order them when dining out.
Consumer Shift Away from Restaurant Desserts
Steady Dessert Consumption: Overall sweet treat consumption hasn’t declined; instead, more consumers are choosing to buy treats elsewhere or make them at home.
Reasons for the Shift:
Price Sensitivity: Higher dessert prices are deterring restaurant patrons.
Availability & Convenience: Store-bought and homemade desserts often cost less and are easy to access.
Where Consumers Are Turning for Desserts
Retail Outlets/Grocery Stores: Up 4% since 2021, now at 39%.
Homemade Desserts: Increased by 5% in the last three years, now at 38%.
Segment Impact
Fast-Casual Decline: Down 6% in dessert purchases.
Fast Food: Down 3% for dessert items.
Dessert-Focused Concepts: Holding steady; no significant drop noted.
Casual Dining: Slight decline of just 1%, indicating a relatively stable dessert attachment rate.
Menu Innovations Continue
LTOs & Seasonal Sweets: Despite the downturn, restaurants aren’t shying away from new dessert launches. Between December 2023 and November 2024, new dessert introductions grew from 386 items to 580 across a Technomic-tracked database of 7,000+ operators.
Seasonal Offerings: Items like Cinnamon Apple Cobbler (California Pizza Kitchen) and Apple Crumb Pie Skillet (Ninety Nine Restaurant & Pub) showed strong purchase intent among surveyed consumers.
Ice Cream Desserts Buck the Trend
Ice Cream Prices Down 9% Overall: A result of decreasing prices in specialty ice cream desserts (down 5.3%) and ice cream cake/pie (down 19.1%).
Popularity of Shakes: Concepts like Chick-fil-A’s Peppermint Chip Milkshake, Shake Shack’s Apple Cider Donut Shake, and Wayback Burgers’ Cookie Butter Shake have gained traction.
Key Takeaway
Rising dessert prices at restaurants are pushing consumers to alternatives, resulting in a downturn for dessert orders—particularly within fast casual. While overall dessert consumption remains steady, more people are buying sweets at grocery stores or making them at home. Nonetheless, innovations like seasonal desserts and ice cream-based treats—which are more cost-stable—still capture consumer interest and help sustain dessert category sales.
Trend
A value-driven reallocation of dessert purchases to lower-cost retail and homemade options, offset by stable interest in unique, seasonal restaurant desserts and notably lower-priced ice cream treats.
Consumer Motivation
Cost Awareness: Avoiding high restaurant dessert markups.
Convenience & Variety: Supermarkets and at-home desserts offer flexibility, affordability, and creative potential.
Satisfaction of Occasional Treats: Demand for indulgence remains; consumers simply pursue alternative avenues for sweet fixes.
Driving the Trend
Menu Price Increases: Dessert upcharges contribute to reduced dining-out frequency for sweets.
Innovation & Marketing: Seasonal limited-time offers and ice cream-based desserts remain appealing, effectively capturing consumer dollars despite overall declines.
Demographic & Format Shifts: Fast casuals see the largest drop, while full-service and dessert-only concepts fare relatively better.
Motivation Beyond the Trend
Restaurant Revenue Streams: Chains use limited-time dessert offers to drive check averages, while specializing in high-margin ice cream shakes.
Operational Adjustments: Some restaurants may minimize or revamp dessert menus to adapt to changing consumer behaviors.
Target Audience
Cost-Conscious Diners: Monitoring restaurant bills closely and opting for cheaper dessert alternatives.
Sweet-Tooth Consumers: Sweets still matter, but location of purchase shifts from restaurant to grocery aisle or home kitchen.
Brand-Loyal Fans of Seasonal Items: Enthusiasts who follow LTOs for unique dessert flavors.
Description of Products or Services
Seasonal Baked Desserts: Apple cobblers, crumb pies, and other limited-time offerings that capture nostalgic cravings.
Ice Cream Specials & Shakes: Typically lower in price or stable in cost, these desserts capitalize on consumer love for indulgent, easy-to-consume treats.
Conclusions
While dessert remains an integral part of American consumers’ overall consumption habits, rising restaurant dessert prices and shifting consumer value propositions are driving a noticeable migration toward less expensive in-home or store-bought treats. However, targeted innovation, especially around ice cream and seasonal flavors, continues to give restaurants competitive opportunities in the dessert category.
Implications for Brands
Competitive Pricing & Promotions: Address cost sensitivity with special deals or combos (e.g., discount or add-on pricing).
Ice Cream Advantage: Leverage stable or decreasing costs for ice cream-based menu items to maintain strong dessert sales.
Seasonal Strategies: Rotate creative LTO desserts to spark consumer curiosity and combat dessert attrition.
Cross-Promotional Partnerships: Collaborate with grocery brands or local bakeries for partial homemade kits or co-branded items.
Implications for Society
Shifting Consumer Behaviors: More at-home baking, broader use of prepared grocery-store desserts, and reliance on retail for sweet cravings.
Culinary Creativity at Home: Consumers may experiment with homemade recipes, especially in cost-conscious environments.
Service Industry Impact: Restaurants may realign dessert offerings or marketing approaches, affecting vendor relationships and product development.
Implications for Consumers
Increased Choice: A wider array of retail dessert brands, along with the freedom to customize recipes at home.
Potential Savings: Opting out of pricier restaurant sweets can make the overall dining-out experience more affordable.
Incentivized Loyalty: Seasonal and LTO items provide reasons to occasionally splurge on restaurant desserts.
Implications for the Future
Sustained Price Sensitivity: With inflationary pressures continuing, expect dessert cost scrutiny to remain a factor.
Possibility of Hybrid Approaches: Some restaurants may offer partial DIY kits or partner with grocery chains to capture revenue from home-based dessert prep.
Tech & Delivery Impact: As third-party dessert-focused platforms grow, restaurants could explore specialized dessert delivery or ghost concepts.
Consumer Trend
A continued focus on value and convenience for sweet indulgences, with price-driven channel shifts from restaurants to retail or home-baking—except in cases where seasonal excitement, promotions, and novelty entice diners to order dessert out.
Consumer Sub Trend
Ice cream’s stable cost and high treat factor enable it to stand out, fueling interest in shakes and specialty ice cream creations.
Big Social Trend
Value-centric decisions shaping how consumers satisfy their dessert cravings, as inflationary pressures redefine standard dining-out behavior.
Local Trend
Fast casual operations see the steepest dessert decline, highlighting the competitiveness in mid-tier dining segments.
Worldwide Social Trend
Restaurants globally face similar margin pressures, but the U.S. context especially underscores that inflation affects all menu categories, directing consumers to cheaper dessert solutions.
Name of the Big Trend Implied by Article
“Cost-Conscious Dessert Shifts”
Name of Big Social Trend Implied by Article
“Value-Driven Indulgence”
Social Drive
A collective push toward budget-friendly sweet solutions that don’t compromise on indulgence—only on the price markups seen in restaurant dining.
Learnings for Companies to Use in 2025
Strategize Pricing & Promotion: Align dessert costs with perceived value to keep them appealing as an add-on.
Highlight Seasonal & Limited-Time Offers: Generate hype and exclusivity to sway consumers from at-home solutions.
Optimize Ice Cream Menus: Capitalize on reduced ice cream prices to bolster dessert sales.
Strategy Recommendations for Companies to Follow in 2025
Revisit Dessert Price Points: Adjust or bundle dessert offerings to balance rising menu prices with consumer expectations.
Focus on Experience: Emphasize novelty and premium touches in limited-service or casual environments to justify dessert splurges.
Expand Take-Home Options: Consider smaller dessert formats or meal kits consumers can finish at home.
Innovate with Ice Cream & Seasonal Flavors: Continually rotate unique shakes, sundaes, or festival-themed sweets to maintain momentum.
Final Sentence (Key Concept)
The main trend from the article is a shift in dessert consumption habits driven by rising restaurant dessert prices, leading budget-conscious consumers to purchase sweets from retail outlets or bake them at home, while ice cream-based items remain a bright spot for operators.
What Brands & Companies Should Do in 2025 to Benefit from the Trend
Restaurants and dessert-focused businesses should innovate around cost-effective, high-appeal desserts, leveraging seasonal LTOs and affordable ice cream creations to retain dessert-seeking customers. Bundling and promotional tactics, combined with creative menu concepts, can help sustain dessert sales in an environment where value-conscious consumers increasingly opt for cheaper homemade and grocery-bought treats.
Final Note
By implementing these strategies, operators can effectively navigate the cost-conscious dessert shift, ensuring their sweet offerings remain compelling despite rising menu prices and intensified competition from at-home or retail dessert solutions.
Kommentit