top of page

Insight of the Day: Food industry trust in the dumps, but things are looking up

Writer's picture: InsightTrendsWorldInsightTrendsWorld
  • Why Food industry trust in the dumps": This part reflects the overall finding of the EIT Food Consumer Observatory survey: consumer trust in the food industry is still persistently low. The trust levels for manufacturers (47%), retailers (51%), and even food authorities (46%) are all below or just slightly above the halfway mark. This indicates a general lack of confidence among European consumers in the food system. Key factors contributing to this "dump" in trust include:   

    • Lack of Transparency: Consumers feel the industry is not open enough about how food is produced, processed, and sourced.

    • Perceived Profit-Driven Motives:  There's a widespread belief that the food industry prioritizes profit over consumer well-being and ethical practices.

    • Information Confusion: Consumers are struggling to discern reliable food information from misinformation, further eroding trust in industry sources.

    •   Practices like Shrinkflation: Actions like shrinkflation reinforce the perception of profit-seeking at the expense of consumers.   

  • "but things are looking up": This part refers to the marginal increase in trust observed across all sectors compared to the previous year's survey. While still low, the trust ratings for manufacturers, retailers, and farmers, and food authorities all increased by 1% or 2%. This slight upward trend suggests that:

    • Industry Efforts are Having a Minor Impact: The article mentions the industry is focusing on communicating competence and concern for areas like sustainability, health, quality, and animal welfare. These efforts, though not yet transformative, might be starting to register with consumers, leading to the slight increase.

    • Potential for Future Improvement: The "looking up" aspect offers a glimmer of hope. It indicates that rebuilding trust is possible, even if it's a slow and ongoing process. The article emphasizes that by focusing on transparency, honest communication, and ethical practices, the industry has a significant opportunity to further improve consumer trust in the future.

Why it is the topic trending:

Consumer trust in the food industry is a critical and trending topic because it directly impacts purchasing decisions, brand loyalty, and the overall stability of the food system. Amidst rising consumer scrutiny and declining confidence, understanding and addressing the trust deficit is paramount for food businesses.

Overview:

A recent EIT Food Consumer Observatory survey reveals that consumer trust in the food industry remains low across Europe, although there's a marginal increase compared to the previous year. Farmers are the most trusted, while manufacturers and food authorities lag significantly behind. Lack of transparency, perceived profit-orientation, and consumer confusion about reliable information are key drivers of this low trust.

Detailed findings:

  • Low Trust Overall: Consumer trust in the food system is still at a relatively low level despite slight improvements.

  • Manufacturer Trust Lowest: Only 47% of European consumers trust food manufacturers, a mere 1% increase from last year.

  • Retailer Trust Slightly Higher: Retailers fare slightly better at 51% trust, also up 1% year-on-year.

  • Farmers Most Trusted: Farmers enjoy a relatively high trust rating of 67%, with a 2% increase.

  • Food Authorities Mistrusted: Food authorities like EFSA are trusted by only 46% of consumers, up 1%.

  • Consumer Confidence Declining:  Low trust coincides with declining consumer confidence, leading to more cautious spending and brand scrutiny.

  • Lack of Transparency: Consumers perceive a significant lack of transparency in the food industry, especially regarding sustainability and animal welfare.

  • Information Confusion: Only 45% of consumers feel confident in distinguishing reliable from unreliable food information.

  • Industry Seen as Profit-Oriented: Many consumers believe the food industry is primarily driven by profit, fueled by practices like shrinkflation.

  • Need for Better Communication:  The industry needs to improve communication to eliminate confusion and misinformation and focus on transparency and openness.

  • Self-Regulation & Collaboration:  Strong self-regulation in messaging, third-party endorsements, and collaboration with authorities and NGOs are essential to build trust.

  • Trust is Key to Success: Consumer trust is a prerequisite for successful food product marketing and commercial success.

Key takeaway:

Consumer trust in the food industry is fragile and remains low due to perceived lack of transparency and profit-driven motives. To restore trust, the industry must prioritize clear, honest communication, transparency in practices, and collaboration with trusted third parties.

Main trend:

Erosion of Food Industry Trust.  Consumer trust in the food industry, particularly manufacturers and authorities, is persistently low and fragile, despite marginal improvements.

Description of the trend (name it):

Fragile Food Faith: This trend describes the precarious state of consumer trust in the food industry. It highlights a consistent lack of confidence in manufacturers, retailers, and regulatory bodies, driven by concerns over transparency, ethics, and information reliability. While there are slight upticks in trust, the overall sentiment remains weak and vulnerable to negative events.

What is consumer motivation:

Consumers are motivated by a desire for transparency, honesty, and reliability from the food industry. They want to understand how their food is produced, where ingredients are sourced, and whether the information they receive is trustworthy. They seek reassurance that the industry prioritizes more than just profit, and is concerned with ethical and sustainable practices.

What is driving trend:

  • Lack of Transparency:  Insufficient information about food production processes, sourcing, and ingredient origins.

  • Perceived Profit-Orientation:  Belief that the industry prioritizes profit over consumer well-being and ethical practices.

  • Information Overload & Confusion: Difficulty in distinguishing reliable food information from misinformation.

  • Shrinkflation & Unethical Practices:  Practices like shrinkflation erode consumer confidence and fuel distrust.

  • Declining Consumer Confidence:  General economic uncertainty and declining consumer confidence amplify scrutiny of brands and spending decisions.

Motivation beyond the trend:

Beyond immediate concerns about food quality and safety, the underlying motivation is a broader desire for an ethical and sustainable food system. Consumers are increasingly concerned about the environmental and social impact of food production and want to support industries that operate responsibly and transparently. This reflects a growing societal value shift towards conscious consumption and corporate accountability.

Description of consumers article is referring to:

  • Age:  Broad European consumer base, likely spanning various age groups as food trust is a universal concern.

  • Gender:  Likely relevant across genders as food trust is a general consumer concern.

  • Income:  Likely affects consumers across income levels, although those with tighter budgets may be more sensitive to issues like shrinkflation and value for money.

  • Lifestyle:  Likely includes a broad range of lifestyles, but particularly relevant to those who are engaged with food issues, health-conscious, environmentally aware, and actively seek information about the products they consume. These consumers are likely digitally connected and access information online.

Conclusions:

Consumer trust in the food industry is critically low and fragile, hindering industry progress and consumer confidence. While there are marginal improvements in trust, current efforts are insufficient to significantly shift public opinion. The industry must prioritize transparency, honest communication, and demonstrate genuine concern for consumer values beyond profit to rebuild trust.

Implications for brands:

  • Transparency is Paramount: Brands must prioritize radical transparency in their sourcing, production, and communication.

  • Honest Communication:  Messaging must be clear, honest, and avoid misleading claims.

  • Ethical Practices:  Demonstrate commitment to ethical sourcing, sustainability, and animal welfare.

  • Third-Party Validation: Seek credible third-party endorsements to enhance trustworthiness.

  • Consumer Engagement: Engage in open dialogue with consumers, addressing concerns and building relationships.

  • Trust as a Core Value:  Integrate trust-building into the core of brand strategy and operations for long-term success.

Implication for society:

  • Weakened Food System: Low trust undermines the stability and effectiveness of the food system.

  • Increased Consumer Skepticism:  Societal cynicism towards the food industry and its motives may deepen.

  • Demand for Regulation:  Public pressure for stronger regulation and oversight of the food industry may increase.

  • Shift to Trusted Brands:  Consumers may increasingly favor brands perceived as transparent and ethical, potentially impacting market dynamics.

Implications for consumers:

  • Information Overload & Confusion: Consumers continue to struggle with navigating complex and often conflicting food information.

  • Careful Spending Decisions:  Consumers will remain cautious and scrutinize food brands and products more closely before purchasing.

  • Demand for Transparency: Consumers will increasingly demand transparency and accountability from food companies.

  • Potential for Mistrust & Cynicism:  Continued low trust can lead to increased consumer cynicism and disengagement with the food industry.

Implication for Future:

In the future, transparency and trust will become even more critical differentiators in the food industry. Brands that proactively build trust through open communication, ethical practices, and third-party validation will gain a competitive advantage. Technology may play a larger role in enhancing transparency and traceability in food supply chains. Consumer demand for sustainable and ethically produced food will continue to rise, further emphasizing the need for trust-building measures.

Consumer Trend (name, detailed description):

Radical Food Transparency: Consumers are demanding unprecedented levels of transparency from food companies, wanting complete visibility into sourcing, production processes, ethical practices, and information validation. This goes beyond basic labeling and requires open communication and demonstrable accountability.

Consumer Sub Trend (name, detailed description):

Third-Party Trust Validation: Consumers are increasingly relying on third-party endorsements, certifications, and independent expert opinions to validate food industry claims. Trust in direct industry messaging is low, making external validation crucial for building credibility.

Big Social Trend (name, detailed description):

Age of Accountability:  Across industries, there is a growing societal demand for accountability and ethical behavior from corporations. Consumers expect businesses to be responsible and transparent in their operations and impact on society and the environment.

Worldwide Social Trend (name, detailed description):

Global Trust Deficit:  A broader global trend of declining trust in institutions and industries, including the food sector. This is driven by factors like information overload, misinformation, and perceived corporate misconduct, requiring global solutions to rebuild confidence.

Social Drive (name, detailed description):

Ethical and Sustainable Consumption:  A strong social drive towards ethical and sustainable consumption is pushing consumers to scrutinize food choices and demand responsible practices from the food industry. This drive is fueled by concerns about health, environment, and social justice.

Learnings for brands to use in 2025:

  • Embrace Radical Transparency:  Make supply chains, production processes, and data openly accessible to consumers.

  • Prioritize Honest Communication:  Communicate clearly, truthfully, and proactively about all aspects of your business.

  • Invest in Ethical & Sustainable Practices:  Demonstrate genuine commitment to ethical sourcing, animal welfare, and environmental sustainability.

  • Seek Third-Party Certification:  Obtain credible third-party certifications to validate claims and enhance trust.

  • Engage in Open Dialogue:  Actively listen to consumer concerns, respond transparently, and build ongoing relationships.

Strategy Recommendations for brands to follow in 2025:

  • Transparency-Focused Marketing:  Develop marketing campaigns that highlight transparency initiatives and provide concrete evidence of ethical practices.

  • "Open Kitchen" Initiatives:  Offer virtual or in-person tours and behind-the-scenes access to production facilities and supply chains.

  • Blockchain for Traceability:  Implement blockchain technology to provide consumers with verifiable traceability of ingredients and products.

  • Partner with Trusted NGOs & Experts:  Collaborate with reputable NGOs and independent experts to endorse products and messaging.

  • Consumer Feedback Platforms:  Create platforms for open consumer feedback and transparently address concerns.

Final sentence (key concept) describing main trend from article:

Fragile Food Faith underscores the urgent need for the food industry to rebuild consumer trust through radical transparency and ethical practices in an era of heightened scrutiny.

What brands & companies should do in 2025 to benefit from trend and how to do it:

In 2025, brands should prioritize building Radical Food Transparency into their core operations and communication strategies to benefit from the growing consumer demand for trust. This can be achieved by:

  • Implementing Transparency Technologies: Invest in technologies like blockchain to offer verifiable traceability and supply chain visibility to consumers through QR codes or online platforms.

  • Creating "Honesty Campaigns": Launch marketing campaigns that directly address consumer trust concerns, highlighting specific transparency initiatives and ethical commitments with data and evidence.

  • Building Direct Consumer Relationships:  Establish direct communication channels with consumers through online forums, social media, and feedback platforms to foster open dialogue and address concerns proactively.

  • Undergoing Independent Audits & Certifications:  Voluntarily submit to regular independent audits and certifications from reputable organizations to validate ethical and sustainable practices and communicate these credentials clearly to consumers.

Final Note:

  • Core Trend: Fragile Food Faith - Persistently low consumer trust in the food industry.

  • Core Strategy: Radical Transparency & Ethical Practice - Brands must prioritize transparency and ethics to rebuild trust.

  • Core Industry Trend: Transparency as Competitive Advantage - Transparency is becoming a key differentiator and competitive advantage in the food industry.

  • Core Consumer Motivation: Desire for Trustworthy & Ethical Food - Consumers are motivated by a fundamental need to trust the food they consume and seek ethical and sustainable options.

  • Final Conclusion: The Fragile Food Faith trend signifies a critical juncture for the food industry, demanding a fundamental shift towards radical transparency and ethical practices to regain consumer trust and ensure long-term success in a market increasingly driven by values and accountability.

Comments


bottom of page