Entertainment: Most Consumers Wary of Fully AI-Generated Creative Content: Exclusive Survey
- InsightTrendsWorld
- Mar 27
- 9 min read
Why it is the topic trending :
Prevalence of Generative AI: The rapid advancement and increasing use of generative AI in content creation across various media formats make consumer attitudes towards it a significant and trending topic.
Impact on Media and Entertainment Industry: Understanding consumer willingness to engage with AI-generated content is crucial for decision-makers in the media and entertainment industry as they navigate the integration of this technology.
Consumer Trust and Authenticity: The survey highlights consumer concerns about the authenticity, originality, and human influence in content created by AI, tapping into broader discussions about the role of AI in society and its impact on human creativity.
Shifting Consumer Sentiment: The article points out an increase in consumer disinterest in fully AI-generated content compared to the previous year, indicating an evolving public perception.
Ethical Considerations of AI Content: Questions surrounding disclosure of AI involvement and the potential displacement of human creators contribute to the trending nature of this topic.
Overview:
The article discusses the findings of a Baringa survey that reveals a significant majority of global consumers are uncomfortable with wholly AI-generated or AI-assisted creative content across various media types like books, films, and music. The survey of over 5,000 respondents across multiple countries highlights that this discomfort stems from a preference for content perceived as more authentic, original, and influenced by human creativity. While quality plays a role in acceptance for some, a substantial portion of consumers remain wary of fully AI-generated content regardless of its quality, with disinterest in such content increasing from the previous year. The article emphasizes the importance of disclosure regarding AI involvement in content creation to build consumer trust and navigate potential backlash.
Detailed Findings:
70% of global consumers would be uncomfortable consuming fully AI-generated creative content.
54% would be uncomfortable with AI-assisted creative content.
For a third of consumers, discomfort would prevent them from engaging with fully AI-generated content altogether.
Only about one in ten consumers say they’d be “very happy” with wholly AI-generated content.
Over a third would prefer always having the content they consume be created by humans.
35% would never be happy to consume entirely AI-generated content under any circumstances, up from 29% last year.
37% said they’d be happy to consume AI content if it was as high quality as human-made (though this was down from 44% last year).
The biggest reasons consumers valued human-made over AI-generated content were perceived greater authenticity and originality, and the influence of the human creator.
Most consumers (24% for wholly AI-generated, 53% for partly AI-generated) want disclosures about when and how AI was used and the humans involved in content creation.
61% would like to see creative companies taking the lead on disclosure.
Consumer backlash has already occurred when AI use in content creation was revealed.
Key Takeaway:
The majority of consumers currently prefer media content created by humans, expressing significant discomfort and even outright rejection of fully AI-generated content due to concerns about authenticity, originality, and the lack of human creative influence, even if the quality is high.
Main Trend: The Enduring Value of Human Creativity in Content Consumption
Description of the trend: This trend underscores the strong and persistent preference of consumers for creative content that is primarily produced by humans, highlighting the value they place on authenticity, originality, and the human element in artistic expression, even as generative AI technology advances.
What is consumer motivation:
Seeking Authenticity: Consumers value the genuine expression and unique perspective that human creators bring to content.
Appreciating Originality: There is a desire for new and innovative ideas that stem from human imagination and creativity, rather than algorithms.
Connecting with Human Experience: Content created by humans often reflects shared experiences, emotions, and insights that resonate deeply with audiences.
Supporting Artists and Creators: Consumers may want to support human artists and creative professionals and their livelihoods.
Valuing Human Influence: Knowing there is a human behind the content adds a layer of meaning and connection for many consumers.
What is driving trend:
Familiarity with Human-Created Content: Traditional media and art forms have long been dominated by human creators, shaping consumer expectations and preferences.
Concerns About AI Limitations: Consumers may perceive AI-generated content as lacking the emotional depth, nuance, and originality of human work.
Ethical Considerations: Questions around copyright, ownership, and the potential displacement of human artists by AI contribute to a preference for human-created content.
The "Human Touch": Many believe that human creators bring a unique and irreplaceable element to artistic expression that AI cannot replicate.
What is motivation beyond the trend:
Beyond the realm of media consumption, this trend might reflect:
A Broader Appreciation for Human Skill and Talent: Consumers value the expertise and dedication involved in human creation across various fields.
The Importance of the Human Element in Society: There is a fundamental recognition of the unique contributions and value of human beings in all aspects of life.
Description of consumers article is referring to:
The article refers to global consumers who participated in a Baringa survey in January 2025. This included a total of 5,004 respondents from:
The U.S.
The U.K.
Australia
The Netherlands
Germany
The survey included a broad range of respondents, and while the article mentions that younger generations were less likely to completely dismiss AI content, it also notes that every age group showed an increase in disinterest in fully AI-generated content. Specific details regarding gender, income, and lifestyle are not provided in the article.
Conclusions:
The Baringa survey concludes that most consumers prefer media content produced by humans, expressing discomfort with fully AI-generated or AI-assisted content due to a perceived lack of authenticity, originality, and human creative influence. While quality can sway some, a significant portion of consumers remain fundamentally disinterested in entirely AI-generated content, with this sentiment increasing. The survey highlights the importance of transparency through disclosure regarding AI involvement in content creation.
Implications for brands:
Transparency is Key: Media and entertainment companies should prioritize clear disclosure about the use of AI in their content creation processes.
Highlight Human Creators: Emphasize the role and influence of human artists and creative professionals involved in content production.
Focus on Authenticity and Originality: Continue to prioritize and market the unique human element in content creation.
Cautious Integration of AI: Proceed with caution when incorporating AI into creative processes, being mindful of potential consumer backlash.
Balance Efficiency with Consumer Preference: While AI offers potential for efficiency, it's crucial to balance this with consumer desires for human-created content.
Implication for society:
Potential Impact on Creative Industries: The preference for human-created content could influence the future role and value of artists and creative professionals in an AI-driven world.
Ongoing Dialogue about AI Ethics: Consumer attitudes towards AI in content contribute to the broader societal conversation about the ethical implications of AI across various sectors.
Implications for consumers:
Demand for Clear Labeling: Consumers are likely to increasingly expect clear information about the origin and creation process of the media they consume.
Continued Choice in Content Consumption: Despite the rise of AI, consumers will likely continue to have a strong preference for and access to human-created content.
Implication for Future:
Consumer attitudes towards AI in content will likely continue to evolve as AI technology becomes more sophisticated and prevalent. However, the fundamental value placed on human creativity, authenticity, and originality suggests that human creators will continue to play a central role in the media and entertainment landscape. Transparency and effective disclosure of AI use will be crucial in shaping consumer acceptance.
Consumer Trend (name, detailed description): The Human-First Content Movement
Detailed Description: This consumer trend reflects a strong and growing preference for creative content where the primary driving force and influence are human creators. Consumers seek the authenticity, originality, and emotional connection that they associate with human artistic expression over content solely generated by artificial intelligence.
Consumer Sub Trend (name, detailed description): The Demand for AI Content Disclosure
Detailed Description: This sub-trend highlights the increasing expectation among consumers that media and entertainment companies will be transparent about when and how artificial intelligence has been used in the creation of content. Consumers want to understand the level of AI involvement and the role of human creators to make informed decisions about what they consume.
Big Social Trend (name, detailed description): The Preservation of Human Creativity in the Age of AI
Detailed Description: As AI becomes more integrated into various aspects of life, there is a growing societal focus on the importance of preserving and celebrating human creativity and artistic expression. This trend manifests in a preference for content that is genuinely human-made.
Worldwide Social Trend (name, detailed description): The Global Wariness Towards Fully Automated Creation
Detailed Description: Across different cultures and regions, there is a general sense of caution and unease regarding the idea of creative content being entirely generated by artificial intelligence, stemming from concerns about the loss of human touch, originality, and ethical implications.
Social Drive (name, detailed description): The Intrinsic Value of Human Connection and Expression
Detailed Description: A fundamental human drive is the need to connect with others and experience authentic forms of self-expression. Consumers seek out human-created content as a means of fulfilling this drive through shared emotions, perspectives, and creative insights.
Learnings for brands to use in 2025 (bullets, detailed description):
Be prepared for consumer skepticism towards fully AI-generated creative content.
Prioritize and showcase the human element in your content creation processes.
Develop clear and transparent policies for disclosing the use of AI in content.
Understand that high quality alone may not be enough to overcome consumer preference for human-made content.
Focus on the authenticity and originality that human creators bring to your brand's content.
Strategy Recommendations for brands to follow in 2025 (bullets, detail description):
Implement clear and consistent disclosure mechanisms for any AI-generated or AI-assisted content.
Develop marketing campaigns that highlight the human creators behind your brand's media.
Invest in and support human artists, writers, and performers.
Gather consumer feedback on their perceptions of AI in your content and adjust strategies accordingly.
Explore hybrid workflows that integrate AI tools while maintaining a central role for human creativity and oversight.
Final sentence (key concept) describing main trend from article: A Baringa survey reveals a significant consumer preference for human-created media content, with discomfort and increasing disinterest in fully AI-generated content driven by a desire for authenticity, originality, and the influence of human creativity.
What brands & companies should do in 2025 to benefit from trend and how to do it:
In 2025, media and entertainment companies should prioritize transparency and the human element in their content creation to align with strong consumer preferences. They should:
Establish clear disclosure practices to inform consumers about the use of AI in any aspect of their content.
Showcase and celebrate human creators involved in their projects to emphasize authenticity and originality.
Focus on content that resonates with human experiences and emotions, as this is a key differentiator from AI-generated material.
Final Note:
Core Trend: Human Content Reigns Supreme
Detailed Description: Despite the advancements in artificial intelligence and its increasing capability to generate creative content, the fundamental preference of consumers remains strongly rooted in content created by human beings. This stems from a deep-seated appreciation for the unique qualities that human creators bring, such as emotional depth, genuine perspective, and original thought, which are often perceived as lacking in fully AI-generated works.
Core Strategy: Prioritize Transparency and the Human Element
Detailed Description: For media and entertainment companies navigating the evolving landscape of content creation, the most effective strategy for 2025 involves a dual focus. Firstly, maintaining transparent communication with consumers about the extent to which AI is involved in their creative processes is crucial for building trust. Secondly, actively highlighting and celebrating the contributions of human artists, writers, musicians, and filmmakers will reinforce the value and authenticity that consumers seek.
Core Industry Trend: Balancing AI Efficiency with Human Value
Detailed Description: The media and entertainment industry is grappling with the potential for increased efficiency and cost savings offered by generative AI technologies. However, there is a parallel recognition of the enduring value and consumer preference for human creativity. The core industry trend in 2025 will likely involve finding a balance between leveraging AI as a tool to assist human creators and preserving the central role and influence of human artistry to meet consumer demand.
Core Consumer Motivation: Seeking Authentic and Original Human Expression
Detailed Description: The primary driving force behind consumer preference for human-made content is the innate desire to connect with authentic and original forms of expression that resonate with the human experience. Consumers seek out the unique perspectives, emotions, and creativity that stem from human imagination and artistic skill, and this motivation outweighs a sole focus on quality when it comes to the media they choose to consume.
Final Conclusion: The findings of the Baringa survey indicate that in 2025, consumers overwhelmingly value human creativity in media content, urging brands to be transparent about AI use and to continue prioritizing and celebrating the unique contributions of human artists to maintain audience trust and engagement.
Core Trend Detailed (name, detailed summary):
Name: Human Content Reigns Supreme
Detailed Summary: People who consume media like books, movies, and music strongly prefer content made by humans. They find it more real, original, and appreciate knowing a human created it. Even if AI can make high-quality content, most people still aren't comfortable with media that's fully made by AI and want to see the human touch
Comments