top of page

Confectionery: The better-for-you candy conundrum: Big potential, slow uptake

Writer: InsightTrendsWorldInsightTrendsWorld
  • Why is the topic trending?

    • Growing Consumer Awareness: There's increasing consumer awareness and interest in healthier food options across various categories, including confectionery. This is driven by a broader societal focus on health and wellness.

    • Manufacturer Innovation: Confectionery brands are actively developing and launching better-for-you (BFY) products, indicating an industry-wide recognition of this trend.

    • Market Data Showing Potential: Reports like the "State of Treating Report 2025" highlight the potential of the BFY confectionery market, even amidst economic pressures.

    • Media Attention: Publications like confectionerynews.com are covering this topic, indicating its relevance within the food industry.

  • Overview: The article explores the paradox of the better-for-you (BFY) candy market. While a significant portion of US consumers recognizes and expresses interest in healthier confectionery options (such as reduced sugar, organic, and dark chocolate), the actual purchase rates remain low. This gap between awareness and action presents a challenge and an opportunity for confectionery brands.

  • Detailed Findings:

    • High Awareness, Low Purchase: 62% of consumers recognize BFY confectionery, but only 10% frequently purchase these products.

    • Consumer Mindset: A key challenge is the ingrained association of indulgence with unhealthiness. Consumers often believe indulgent foods can't be healthy, even though they acknowledge the importance of indulgence for mental and emotional well-being.

    • Say vs. Do: There's a discrepancy between consumers' stated preference for natural, less indulgent ingredients and their actual purchasing habits, which still favor conventional products.

    • BFY Spans Multiple Trends: The BFY category encompasses various trends like removing artificial ingredients, adding protein, and focusing on overall well-being (sleep, stress, immunity).

      • Removing artificial ingredients:

        • This trend focuses on consumers seeking products with fewer artificial additives.

        • It includes the reduction or elimination of artificial sweeteners, flavors, and colors.

        • Companies like Swedish firm Tweek are mentioned, whose candies contain significantly less sugar and use all-natural colors and flavorings.

        • UK-based start-up Yumma is another example, selling fruit-flavored gummies made with real juice and fruit pieces.

        • The growth of fruit confections (17% year-on-year according to Nielsen data) indicates the popularity of this trend.

        • Even in chocolate, like Cadbury's Dairy Milk Fruitier & Nuttier, non-HFSS (high in fat, salt, and sugar) options are being introduced, leveraging the "healthy halo effect" of fruit.

      • Adding protein:

        • This trend involves formulating confectionery with added protein to enhance its nutritional value.

        • The positioning of protein bars has shifted from being solely for sports nutrition to being a tasty and convenient snack that supports an active and balanced lifestyle.

        • Ferrero's acquisition of Fulfil Nutrition in 2022 is highlighted as a major confectionery player investing in this segment. Fulfil Nutrition aims to appeal to consumers looking for functional, better-for-you confectionery.

      • Overall wellbeing:

        • This trend goes beyond just ingredient swaps and targets more nuanced consumer needs related to health and wellness.

        • It includes products designed to address concerns like sleep, stress, immunity, and mental health.

        • UK-based chocolatier Wizards Magic is given as an example, offering bars with 0% sugar as well as options with added matcha and CBD for relaxation, chamomile and lavender for sleep, lion’s mane for mental clarity, and acai for detoxification.

        • These types of products often fall into the "permissible indulgence" category and can command a higher price point due to their specialized ingredients and focus on specific health benefits.

    • Specific Examples of BFY Brands: The article mentions Justin's, Cartwright & Butler, Fulfil Nutrition, Tweek, Yumma, Cadbury, and Wizards Magic as brands active in the BFY space, highlighting different approaches like permissible indulgence, functional benefits, and natural ingredients.

    • Growth in Specific BFY Segments: Fruit confections with natural ingredients are showing significant year-on-year growth (17%).

  • Key Takeaway: While there is a growing awareness and interest in better-for-you confectionery, brands need to bridge the gap between consumer desire and actual purchase by addressing the mindset around indulgence versus health, clearly communicating benefits, and focusing on taste and experience.

  • Main Trend: The "Healthy Indulgence Gap": This trend describes the disconnect between consumers' increasing awareness and interest in healthier candy options and their relatively low rate of actual purchase, primarily because of the perceived conflict between "healthy" and "indulgent."

  • Description of the Trend (please name it): Healthy Indulgence Gap - This trend is characterized by a consumer segment that is increasingly informed about health and wellness and expresses a desire for healthier versions of their favorite treats, like candy. However, when it comes to actual purchases, these consumers often revert to more traditional, often less healthy, options. This gap is driven by a variety of factors including ingrained perceptions of candy as purely indulgent, skepticism about the taste and satisfaction of healthier alternatives, and potentially a lack of clear understanding or trust in the "better-for-you" claims.

  • What is consumer motivation? Consumers are motivated by a desire to balance their enjoyment of sweet treats with their health and wellness goals. They are seeking ways to indulge without feeling guilty or compromising their health.

  • What is driving trend? The trend is driven by:

    • Growing health consciousness among consumers.

    • Increased availability of information about nutrition and ingredients.

    • Rising interest in functional foods and ingredients that offer health benefits.

    • Innovations from confectionery brands attempting to cater to this demand.

  • What is motivation beyond the trend? Beyond the specific BFY candy trend, the underlying motivation is a broader shift towards preventative health and a more holistic approach to well-being. Consumers are increasingly proactive in making choices that they believe will positively impact their long-term health, both physically and mentally.

  • Description of consumers article is referring to (what is their age?, what is their gender? What is their income? What is their lifestyle): The article primarily refers to US consumers in general. While it doesn't provide specific demographic details like age, gender, or income, we can infer some characteristics:

    • Age: Likely a broad age range, from children and teenagers who consume candy to adults who snack or enjoy occasional treats. The reference to Gen Z and Millennials in the search history suggests these younger adult demographics are relevant.

    • Gender: Not explicitly stated, likely both male and female consumers are part of this trend.

    • Income: The article notes that even with "economic pressures," consumers are still making room for indulgence, suggesting this trend isn't solely limited to high-income brackets. It likely spans various income levels.

    • Lifestyle: The article mentions consumers "exploring better-for-you confectionery," implying a segment that is at least somewhat health-conscious or trying to make healthier choices within their existing lifestyle. The reference to protein bars' shift from sports-focused to supporting an "active and balanced lifestyle" indicates another relevant consumer segment.

  • Conclusions: The main conclusion is that the BFY candy market holds significant potential, but brands need to overcome the challenges related to consumer perception of indulgence and health. Effective strategies involve balancing classic offerings with innovative BFY options, clearly communicating nutritional benefits, and focusing on taste and sensory experience.

  • Implications for Brands:

    • Innovation is Key: Brands need to continue innovating with ingredients, formulations, and product formats to create BFY options that genuinely appeal to consumers in terms of taste and texture.

    • Clear Communication: Effectively communicating the health benefits and nutritional information of BFY products is crucial to build trust and encourage purchase.

    • Address the Indulgence Perception: Brands need to find ways to position BFY candy as still indulgent and satisfying, perhaps through flavor profiles, textures, or occasions for consumption.

    • Consider Different BFY Angles: Focus on various aspects like natural ingredients, reduced sugar, added protein, or functional benefits to cater to different consumer needs.

    • Pricing Strategy: Be mindful of pricing, as consumers might be hesitant to pay significantly more for BFY options if the perceived value isn't clear.

  • Implication for Society:

    • Potential for healthier dietary habits if BFY options gain wider acceptance.

    • Could contribute to reducing sugar intake and related health issues in the long term.

    • May encourage the food industry to further innovate and offer healthier alternatives across other product categories.

  • Implications for Consumers:

    • Potentially more options for enjoying treats without as much guilt or negative health impact.

    • Opportunity to make choices that better align with their health and wellness goals.

    • May need to pay a premium for BFY options compared to traditional candy.

  • Implication for Future: The future likely holds more growth for the BFY candy market as consumer health consciousness continues to rise and brands become more adept at creating appealing and trustworthy healthier options. The key will be bridging the "Healthy Indulgence Gap."

  • Consumer Trend (name, detailed description): Conscious Snacking: This trend involves consumers being more mindful about their snack choices, considering factors like nutritional content, ingredients, and potential health impacts. They are increasingly looking for snacks that not only taste good but also align with their wellness goals, leading them to explore options like BFY candy.

  • Consumer Sub Trend (name, detailed description): Permissible Indulgence: This sub-trend reflects the desire to enjoy treats and indulge in food pleasures without completely abandoning health goals. Consumers are seeking products that allow them to satisfy cravings in a "better-for-you" way, making options like BFY candy with natural sweeteners or added benefits appealing.

  • Big Social Trend (name, detailed description): Health and Wellness Focus: This overarching social trend reflects a widespread and growing emphasis on physical and mental well-being across society. It influences various aspects of consumer behavior, including food choices, driving the demand for healthier alternatives like BFY candy.

  • Worldwide Social Trend (name, detailed description): Increased Health Awareness: Globally, there's a rising awareness of the impact of diet on health, leading consumers in many regions to seek out healthier food and beverage options. This trend is not limited to the US and has implications for confectionery markets worldwide.

  • Social Drive (name, detailed description): Preventative Health: A key social drive is the increasing emphasis on taking proactive steps to maintain health and prevent future health issues. This motivates consumers to choose foods and snacks that they perceive as healthier, even within traditionally indulgent categories like candy.

  • Learnings for brands to use in 2025 (bullets, detailed description):

    • Focus on Taste First: Health benefits are important, but taste remains the primary driver for candy purchases. BFY options must taste genuinely good to succeed.

    • Transparency is Crucial: Clearly communicate ingredients, nutritional information, and any health benefits. Avoid vague or misleading claims.

    • Highlight the "Indulgence" Aspect: Don't shy away from the fact that it's still a treat. Emphasize the enjoyment and satisfaction while highlighting the "better-for-you" aspects.

    • Cater to Specific Needs: Develop BFY products that target specific consumer needs, such as sugar-free for diabetics, high-protein for active individuals, or those with added functional benefits like stress relief or improved sleep.

    • Leverage Natural Ingredients: Highlight the use of natural colors, flavors, and sweeteners, as this resonates with many health-conscious consumers.

    • Offer Variety in Formats and Portions: Provide different portion sizes and resealable packaging to align with mindful consumption and convenience.

  • Strategy Recommendations for brands to follow in 2025 (bullets, detailed description):

    • Invest in R&D: Continue to invest in research and development to create innovative BFY formulations that don't compromise on taste or texture.

    • Strategic Partnerships: Collaborate with health and wellness influencers or organizations to build credibility and reach target consumers.

    • Omnichannel Marketing: Utilize a variety of marketing channels to educate consumers about the benefits and appeal of BFY candy, including online content, social media, and in-store promotions.

    • Sampling and Trials: Encourage trial through in-store sampling or promotional offers to overcome consumer skepticism.

    • Monitor Consumer Feedback: Continuously monitor consumer feedback and adapt product offerings and marketing strategies accordingly.

  • Final sentence (key concept) describing main trend from article (which is a summary of all trends specified): Despite growing interest, the confectionery industry is still navigating the complexities of the "Healthy Indulgence Gap," where consumer desire for healthier options hasn't fully translated into consistent purchasing behavior.

  • What brands & companies should do in 2025 to benefit from trend and how to do it: In 2025, brands should focus on bridging the Healthy Indulgence Gap by developing BFY candy that truly delivers on taste and satisfaction while clearly communicating health benefits. This can be achieved through:

    • Innovation in Formulation: Utilizing advanced food science to create healthier recipes with appealing textures and flavors, perhaps focusing on natural sweeteners that don't compromise taste.

    • Targeted Marketing: Identifying specific consumer segments (e.g., health-conscious parents, fitness enthusiasts, individuals managing sugar intake) and tailoring marketing messages to their needs and motivations.

    • Building Trust: Being transparent about ingredients and production processes, and potentially seeking certifications or endorsements from reputable health organizations.

    • Creating Excitement: Launching BFY products with innovative flavor combinations or unique textures to generate buzz and attract consumers beyond the health aspect.

  • Final Note:

    • Core Trend:

      • Name: Healthy Indulgence Gap

      • Detailed Description: Consumers are increasingly aware of and interested in healthier candy options, but their actual purchase behavior still leans towards traditional, often less healthy choices, indicating a gap between desire and action due to the perceived trade-off between health and indulgence.

    • Core Strategy:

      • Name: Balanced Value Proposition

      • Detailed Description: Brands need to offer BFY candy that provides a compelling balance of health benefits (reduced sugar, natural ingredients, added nutrients) and indulgent taste and experience to motivate consistent consumer purchase.

    • Core Industry Trend:

      • Name: Functional Confectionery

      • Detailed Description: The confectionery industry is increasingly exploring the incorporation of functional ingredients (protein, fiber, vitamins, adaptogens) into candy products to appeal to health-conscious consumers seeking added benefits beyond basic indulgence.

    • Core Consumer Motivation:

      • Name: Guilt-Free Enjoyment

      • Detailed Description: Consumers are motivated by the desire to enjoy sweet treats and satisfy their cravings without experiencing guilt or compromising their health and wellness objectives.

Final Conclusion: The primary challenge and opportunity in the better-for-you candy market in 2025 lie in effectively addressing the "Healthy Indulgence Gap" by creating delicious and truly appealing healthier alternatives that resonate with consumers' desire for guilt-free enjoyment, ultimately bridging the divide between health awareness and purchasing behavior.

Core Trend Detailed:

Name: Healthy Indulgence Gap

Detailed Summary: The "Healthy Indulgence Gap" signifies a significant disconnect in the confectionery market. On one hand, there is a clear and growing segment of consumers who are increasingly health-conscious and express a desire for "better-for-you" candy options. This is evident in their awareness of these products and their stated interest in lower sugar, more natural ingredients, and even added health benefits. On the other hand, the actual purchasing data reveals a different story. Despite this awareness and expressed interest, the frequency of consumers choosing these healthier alternatives remains considerably low, with the majority still opting for traditional, often more indulgent, candy products. This gap is not simply a matter of preference but is influenced by ingrained perceptions that associate candy primarily with pure indulgence, potentially leading to skepticism about whether healthier versions can truly satisfy their cravings or deliver on taste. Furthermore, factors like price, availability, and the perceived value proposition of BFY options compared to familiar favorites also contribute to this lag in purchase. The "Healthy Indulgence Gap" represents a critical challenge for confectionery brands as they attempt to tap into the growing health and wellness trend. To successfully navigate this gap, brands must not only innovate in terms of product formulation to create genuinely appealing healthier options but also strategically address consumer perceptions and motivations through effective communication and marketing that emphasizes both the health benefits and the enjoyable, indulgent aspects of their BFY offerings.

Comentários


bottom of page